I would have to say, this is probably my favorite out of the 3 movies we’ve watched in class so far. In comparison to Triangle, it was not confusing as to whether it was horror or not, and in comparison to Ginger Snaps it most definitely was not annoying or as poorly written or made either. More importantly, it was along the lines of my most preferred branch of horror, which is the sort of meta, thriller type or horror.
Claire and Luke, employees of the Yankee Peddler Inn with a fascination for the paranormal, are in the midst of the inn’s last weekend open.
The Inn itself has a rich history through the story of Madeline O’ Malley, a bride who hung herself in the inn when her husband abandoned her on the night of their honeymoon whose body was supposedly never found because of the hotel owners hiding it in the basement to avoid bad publicity. (I guess from here it was already pretty obvious to us who the ghost in the inn would be, when or if she would ever show up was the real question.)
Later that night, after a famous actress, Leanne, who Claire fangirls over, checks into the hotel, Claire and Luke break off into shifts. As it was decided that Claire would take the first shift, she also had to make the use of an EVP to look for ghosts around the hotel to help Luke with the launching of his ghost hunting website.
While doing this she hears voices and music, upon exploring she even sees the piano playing by itself. Whiles continuing to explore the hotel with her EVP, she runs into Leanne in the hallway who tells her that she left her career as an actress to become a medium and that she was actually in town for a psychic convention. Clairs asks her to confirm whether it is Madeline’s spirit in the inn, and Leanne tells her that there was mistake and 3 spirits present and insisted that she stay away from the basement in particular.
The next morning, Claire wakes up to the ghost of Madeline O’ Malley. (And this ghost, is hella scary. It is not often for them to show the ghost or monster in full clear view in horror movies but to show a ghost as scary as Madeline emphasizes what Carroll referred to as how anomalies in horror films command your attention and elicit curiosity from the audience.)
And I mean ultimately and utterly, SCARY.
It is not often for them to show the ghost or monster in full clear view in horror movies, this is actually the first time for me to watch a movie that shows a ghost in such a way, and for long periods of time at that. This got me thinking that to show a ghost as scary as Madeline emphasizes what Carroll referred to as how anomalies in horror films command your attention and elicit curiosity from the audience because she not only frightens and disgusts you, but at the same time you become fascinated by Madeline and what happened to her all those years ago.)
After an old man checks into the inn and insists on staying in the honeymoon suite on the 3rd floor to relive the old days for the last time (by this point it is unclear who the old man is, but I think it is safe to say that we probably all had an inkling of this man being the old husband of Madeline),
Claire and Luke think it would be a good idea to explore the basement to continue to look for the spirits of the inn.
There they encounter various voices and Claire panics and runs upstairs to tell Leanne while Luke in a state of panic decides to leave the hotel because he is too afraid. Leanne tells Claire that the inn is no longer safe and that they have to leave as soon as possible so Claire tells Leanne to pack while she goes off to call the old man to leave with them as well. When she reaches his room however, she finds that the old man has committed suicide and he left a letter confirming what we all suspected of earlier that he was indeed the husband of Madeline who had run away all those years ago. Aside from the body of the old man in the tub, the ghost of Madeline is seen yet again hanging from the ceiling. In a panic, Claire runs back downstairs.
Luke has returned to the hotel feeling guilty and he rushes upstairs to look for Claire while she is headed towards the basement to look for Leanne. (By this point of course we reach that cliche point of the movie where we find ourselves saying “WTF DON’T BE STUPID, DON’T GO DOWN THERE” and in true horror film fashion, the character does the ultimately stupid thing to do in a scary situation.) While she is looking for Leanne the ghost of the old man appears,
startling her, causing her to trip and fall down the stairs.
While she is in the basement she finds herself in the room where Madeline’s body was kept and while she was fighting to try to open the door and calling for Luke, Claire dies – whether of an asthma attack or a ghost attack by Madeline, we will never know for sure.
The film ends showing Claire’s empty room before the door slams shut on it’s own.
(People say that there is a faint outline of Claire as a ghost standing by the window, but honestly, I still cannot make out the figure despite how many pictures and videos I searched in order to verify this as sometimes I think I see it but then again it could be my mind playing tricks on me from trying to see her outline.)
The recurring theme in this entire movie and in “Why horror?” was essentially curiosity. Curiosity of Claire and Luke for the paranormal, for the truth of what happened to Madeline O’ Malley, and everything in between. While from an audience perspective it’s whether our suspicions or guesses through out the movie will be confirmed. Carroll says that the attraction or pull of horror movies is completely driven by curiosity, and I could not agree with it more.
I enjoyed the movie despite it’s relatively slow pace because of all the shock moments towards the last part that more than compensated for the lack of excitement at first. It had a simple story that was easy to follow with a somewhat predictable plot (given the many guesses that turned out to be right.) but given the entertainment value that one would look for in a horror film, I think The Innkeepers gave what was expected.
However it is enjoying such a movie and other movies with similar plots or themes that makes one think what makes us so drawn to the horror genre in the first place? What is it with people and wanting to scaring yourself shitless about the simplest of things? Why pay sums of money to get the heebie jeebies over ghosts and monsters that we probably would not want to see in a real life situation?
Carroll answers this perfectly in his article that it is in fact the “revelation of the unknown and unknowable, unbelievable and incredible, impossible beings and the fascination of the horror being in tandem with disturbance” that attracts audiences to continue to watch films that are supposedly so disturbing. And it is this disturbing factor that in fact makes us so fascinated with horror to begin with. Making The Innkeepers the perfect movie to amplify such a trait in all of us as the characters in the film itself were attracted and drawn to some anomaly whose existence was eventually confirmed, and possibly confronted.
We are fascinated by horrifying things and images for the mere fact that they are horrifying, making the majority of the success of the horror genre, probably, in general something built on human curiosity amplified by our fascination of the unknown. The horror film industry capitalizes on the unwavering curiosity of adrenaline junkies and scaredy cats alike, and I think this is pretty darn brilliant.
113357